CdM Citizens Group Approves Curvy, Palm-Filled Entryway Plans

posted: December 28th, 2011 10:01 am | 8Comments

Corona del Mar’s revamped entryway at MacArthur Boulevard and East Coast Highway could feature a curvy extra-wide sidewalk, date palm trees, low, curving walls that double as seating and “programmable” sidewalk space that could be used for art and music shows and holiday events.

Members of the Corona del Mar Citizens Advisory Panel voted 3-1 at the group’s December meeting to approve the plans and forward them to the Newport Beach Neighborhood Revitalization Committee. The decision resulted in the CdM CAP group’s being immediately disbanded because it filled its obligations, despite an agenda that listed another January meeting and earlier discussion of outreach efforts to nearby businesses and the Corona del Mar Residents Association.

“The concept plan, while still preliminary and will be refined in future design phases is a very good plan that follows the CdM Vision plan,” said Ron Yeo, a committee member who has been involved in Corona del Mar beautification vision plans for several years, in an email to local leaders. Construction costs will be around $1.3 million, he wrote, and the project could be on the Newport Beach proposed budget in July.

The current plans move the so-called squeeze lane — where three traffic lanes reduce to two lanes — to the west side of MacArthur Boulevard. The former traffic lane would then be used to expand the sidewalk area from about 12 to 33 feet in the block between Begonia and Carnation avenues, while also expanding to a lesser degree the widths between Acacia and Begonia and Carnation and Dahlia avenues.

The changes not only will improve the looks of the area, Yeo said, but it will improve traffic safety for cyclists, motorists and pedestrians.

The changes also will result in the loss of nine parking spaces between Begonia and Carnation avenues because of safety concerns, but the parking places would be replaced in other areas of Corona del Mar, Yeo said.

Specific details, such as park benches, bicycle racks, possible outdoor dining for nearby restaurants and more all remain unresolved.

“All the details will be worked out later,” said CAP member Sandie Haskell. “We could have meetings for the next three years with people saying, ‘We should have this here or put an umbrella there.’ But we were an ad hoc committee formed to come up with the concept. We came up with a concept, and our work was done.”

By moving forward now, she added, the plans would have a better chance of being funded in the city’s next fiscal year, which begins in July.

But the group’s lone dissenting voter said she was concerned that neighbors, property owners, businesses and CdMRA members would “most definitely be caught off guard on this quick decision.”

“I believe we rushed this decision,” Lisa Jordan said in an email. “I am disappointed that we may have not fulfill our agreement to the city. By this vote, we’re essentially handing the full responsibility back over to the city, which was not our direction/job. There are still so many decisions to be made.”

Resident Jim Mosher, who observed the meeting, said he wondered if the group violated the state Brown Act because the meeting’s publicized agenda did not indicate that a vote would be taken and also said the group would meet again on Jan. 25.

In an email, Mosher wrote “(T)here was nothing in the agenda to hint that the CAP would be voting on making a final recommendation to the NRC and folding up shop.”

City spokeswoman Tara Finnigan said that staff will be send notices to community members and property owners before the Jan. 12 Neighborhood Revitalization Committee meeting. The meeting is scheduled for 4 p.m. in Council Chambers at City Hall at 3300 Newport Blvd.

“Public comments on the plans can be made to the Committee and again at the full City Council meeting” at a future date, she said. “So, there is still time for public review and comment and all of the conceptual plans are available online.”

The Corona del Mar Business Improvement District has been working to bring a beautification plan to the MacArthur Boulevard entry point since at least 1999, with revisions to its plan made again in 2004. Originally, the plans included creating a “Restaurant Row” with outdoor dining on the expanded sidewalk space, and part of the process included the relinquishment of Coast Highway from CalTrans to the City of Newport Beach in 2004, which allowed local officials to make improvements to medians along with other changes, like pedestrian crosswalks; read our earlier story here. During this year’s CdM CAP meetings, city officials stated that restaurant owners who want to use the increased sidewalk space for dining would have to have permits and approval from zoning and planning officials.

To see the plans and renderings that were approved this month, click here.

Images courtesy of consultant Dennis Stone, taken from the Newport Beach city website.

8 Responses to “CdM Citizens Group Approves Curvy, Palm-Filled Entryway Plans”

Comments

Frank Peters

December 28th, 2011

As the meeting wound down, parking spaces continued to be a concern, so I suggested that adding bike racks to the still-to-be-configured street furniture arrangements might help, “Nine parking places could be mitigated by adding 18 bike racks.” When this comment caused everyone on the panel to laugh, I was quick to interpret the reaction as acknowledgement of the obvious.

OTGrouch

December 28th, 2011

the laughter was probably the result of contemplation of the prospect of mitigation of parking places.

cdm local

December 28th, 2011

Lots of good ideas which reflect a creative approach. except for the Date Palms, which do not belong in a california landscape.

Dan

December 28th, 2011

Chaired by a paid consultant, the meeting was run informally the first half hour because there was no quorum a few days before Christmas. It was the last public meeting on the City of Newport Beach’s 2011 calendar and Community Development Director Kim Brandt was ready to wrap things up for the holidays. At her urging, the plan was approved even though the chairperson stated he was “uncomfortable with an action to approve a final conceptual plan, because we didn’t notice the meeting that way.” Brandt explained the need to expedite approval so that the plan could be advanced to the January 12 Ad Hoc Neighborhood Revitalization Committee meeting for approval and on to City Council to be worked into the budget for the next fiscal year beginning in July. Impacts on traffic and parking should not concern the committee or conceptual plan, according to Brandt. Furthermore, the expansion of the bars and restaurants into the public “Flex Space” need not be discussed at this time. All that will be worked out later… No residents in the adjacent neighborhoods have been noticed. The plan was not available to the public via the Internet before the meeting because the consultants got “jammed up.” As aside, the raised wedge in the crosswalk at E Coast Hwy and Carnation Ave by Golden Spoon is referred to by the planners as the Pork Chop.

Jamie

December 28th, 2011

What would you rather have? Cactus or CA native scrub brush? Date palms are magnificent - ever been to Palm Springs? Too bad this city hates trees. They wont allow date palms I guarantee it. As for the plan. I give up, do whatever the heck you want, you will anyway, but don't use my tax money to do it.

Laura

December 30th, 2011

I'm concerned about the funding source for this project. Do we have this to spare? Even over and above what we're spending on the new city hall, the Buck Gully Trail, and all those "indispensable" new signs installed in summer. I recently received a mailer from the fire department/ police department that concerned me about potential cuts to those departments' budgets. Safety is a priority! This citizen rests well at night knowing the NBFD would be at my door in 3-4 minutes if I needed them. Thank you CDM Today for bringing my attention to these city matters (I should be more proactive, but let's face it - I'm not).

Julie

January 2nd, 2012

We already suffer with traffic in the summer and over holidays. How are we supposed to get through town if they reduce lanes! And we're always giving good businesses a hard time about coming into town based on available parking, yet we're ok with giving up parking spaces? And, Laura has the best argument of all...with so many businesses still closing in this economy, how are we even thinking about spending dollars on this kind of improvement over continuing our fire and police budgets?! I should be the last one to comment since I never go to the meetings, but it all seems very obvious.

Corona del Mar Today Staff

January 2nd, 2012

Reply to

Julie

January 2, 2012

We already suffer with traffic in the summer and over holidays. How are we supposed to get through town if they reduce lanes! And we're always giving good businesses a hard time about coming into town based on available parking, yet we're ok with giving up parking spaces? And, Laura has the best argument of all...with so many businesses still closing in this economy, how are we even thinking about spending dollars on this kind of improvement over continuing our fire and police budgets?! I should be the last one to comment since I never go to the meetings, but it all seems very obvious.

Apparently the traffic studies show that the flow will be better if the lanes reduce before the MacArthur traffic has to merge, rather than squeezing from three to two right at the same place.


Leave a comment